Fishbone Walkway Design

University of Arkansas, Auburn researchers create model for efficient distribution center design.
V-shaped diagonal aisles allow workers to move through the picking area more quickly. The design is highlighted by parallel, bottom-up, cross-sectional, and diagonal movement lines.
FAYETTEVILLE, Ark. – The Internet and the shift in economic structure toward services have led to a dilemma for logistics and supply chain management: When customers order products online, they expect to receive their items as quickly as possible. A nimble company knows that if they want to compete, they must change the way they store and distribute goods. In this new environment, warehouses – now known as distribution centers – have become more than just places to store products, they are an essential part of the supply and distribution chain. Long Quyen

Researchers from the University of Arkansas and Auburn University have found a solution to make distribution centers more efficient. By helping companies get products off the shelves faster, this discovery will significantly improve the distribution process, meaning customers will receive their products faster.

“Our results show that for each unit of goods, the completely new design leads to faster recovery rates and significantly reduced costs for distribution operations centers,” said Russell Meller, professor of industrial engineering and director of the Center for Logistics and Distribution Engineering at the University of Arkansas.

Meller and Kevin Gue, professor of engineering at Auburn University, studied warehouse shelving configurations and found that despite the increased demand for fast and efficient product distribution, the typical design of distribution centers has not changed. Even conventional designs limit productivity, according to Meller. Specifically, he and Gue found that there were two unaddressed design assumptions, neither of which had been taken into account in the construction perspective, that limited efficiency and productivity because they required workers to travel longer distances and through more side routes to pick products from shelves and deliver them to distribution points. Long Quyen

“For many years, companies treated warehouses almost exclusively as cost centers,” Meller said. “This results in a restrictive design rule that focuses solely on storage density to maximize space utilization. Unfortunately, designing a dedicated storage area to maximize storage density ignores the operational costs of retrieving items from storage shelves.”

The typical design limitations are a parallel system of “picking” side lanes, depending on the size of the distribution center, sometimes separated by one or more cross aisles. In this configuration, the design assumptions are assumed to be:optimal cross-giakelongquyen.com

The diagonal passage goes straight through and cuts all the “picking” passages.
The “pick up” aisles are all straight, and all lead to the diagonal aisle.

Meller and Gue challenge the assumptions that alternative designs have lower storage density but improve order response times.

While a traditional warehouse with 21 picking aisles has no cross aisles, the researchers’ “optimized aisle” model adds two diagonal aisles. Viewed from above, the diagonal aisles form a “V” that bisects the total space of side aisles and racks. This is a simple change for forklift drivers, giving them a “straight-line advantage” when traveling between pick locations. Meller and Gue tested the design and found that it reduced picking costs by 11.2 percent compared to the traditional design. Meller notes that the optimized model has the same total path length as the traditional design, although the space used for aisles increases by 3 percent.

“The key to this design is a diagonal aisle that cuts through the secondary ‘picking’ aisles, allowing pickers to reach multiple picking locations quickly via a more direct route,” says Gue.

For their second alternative design, Meller and Gue kept the V-shaped diagonal aisles and turned some of the side aisles horizontal. Viewed from above, V-shaped diagonal aisles extend from the bottom to the top of the entire space, cutting through the picking aisles and rack rows. Long Quyen

Researchers call this model “Fishbone”. “The side aisles are combined symmetrically through a V-shaped diagonal leading to a more impressive result. Meller conducted tests and found that the cost to execute an option was 20.4 percent lower than in a comparable traditional warehouse.

“Fishbone aisles allow pickers to move much like a direct ‘as the crow flies’ pick,” says Gue.

To demonstrate this, Meller and Gue calculated the expected retrieval time in an imaginary warehouse where workers could theoretically move “as the crow flies” for every pallet location. They found that the imaginary warehouse – which is not achievable – would reduce costs by 23.5 percent when compared to traditional warehouse designs. Long Quyen

“We can say that although the Fishbone design hasfishbone_giakelongquyen.com It may not be the best possible design, but it has implemented almost all possible improvements,” Meller said.

The research results will be published on Goods Distribution Process: 2006. The researchers have applied for patents for the design models and are talking to major retailers about implementing the designs in distribution centers.

“Our approach recognizes the emerging role of the distribution center in industry,” Meller said. “A properly designed distribution center can provide a competitive advantage for businesses in retail and industrial distribution.”

In addition to his position as professor of industrial engineering and director of the Center for Logistics and Distribution Engineering, Meller holds the position of professor of Logistics and Business in the College of Engineering. Long Quyen